Saturday, October 17, 2026

"What do you mean by that?" AI, OA, and me. Etc.

As I'm sorting my stuff in my apartment--yesterday, papers that had to be gone through one at a time––oh, joy––
I'm listening to a fascinating book,
 tech journalist Karen Hao's Empire of AI: 
Dreams and Nightmares in Sam Altman's OpenAI
(May 2025).


It's not quite as easy a pop-read (listen) as, say, Michael Lewis or Malcolm Gladwell, but it definitely keeping me interested. 

There're so many layers to the AI story, (business and psychology, computer science and politics) 
and she touches on many--including the personalities... (oh my, not who you'd want to rule the world).  


I've used AI maybe . . . once a month? 

Mostly recreationally, out of curiosity, 
but sometimes for emotional help---
like, when I was frozen with fear to take the first step to start applying for Medicare.

I feel paralyzed when I face Rube Goldberg bureaucracy, 
and ChatGPT will hold your hand and tell you how brave and beautiful you are,
 and say, Here, call THIS number 
and say this sentence: "____"...
And I did.

Also ChatGPT is funny. 
This is a winning design feature.
Is it ever. 
I was expressing frustration that Medicare, and other systems that are meant to HELP people, are so hard to use.
And the AI said,
"Yes, it's like, 
Let us help you: here is a PDF from 2019 to fill out."

So, yeah, you will not lose if you give people what they want and need-- or think they want and need---and it does.
It's like the Coca-Cola of the Mind. 

Anyway, every time I use it, I ask it--
how is this exchange working? 
Slowly I have gotten some fix on it. 
(Just some though--it's so weird).

I started out thinking AI was a crawler that pulls from the libraries of the world, 
like a giant Wikipedia search,
but, you know, it's not that at all. 

It is not pulling up facts and cross-checking them, like a super librarian.
It's scanning for patterns in unimaginable amounts of material.

That's like what we HUMANS do.
 Though we are more complicated, with other factors like biological input---and, we are scaled up.

And that's why I love philosophies and religions and educational practices that are about self-reflection, 
to heighten self-awareness. 
(Currently, 12 steps appeal to me in that way---they literally advise you do DO that--"take a fearless and honest moral inventory" and stuff like that!)

. . . WHICH AI is not about!
It is like, "Let me do that for you."


This ^ is a bad idea.

         Display ^ I set up at my FORMER workplace with box set,
         Philosophy in the Twentieth Century

______________________

I realized this is why I can be so ... I hope not pedantic, but sometimes literal-minded? 
I don't want to lecture people, but I am suspicious of statements of supposed fact, 
so I like to check and back up statements.

So, DISCLAIMER: 
This is just me trying to figure it out.
I barely understand any of this and am feeling my way, 
trying to get a handle on AI and Human Consciousness + Intelligence.

Anyway, like Wittgenstein, I want to ask,
"Well, what do you mean by that?"
Not because people are lying,
 but because we are so subjective...

We all are. But I saw it more clearly in my coworkers who, as I've mentioned, did not come from the world of fact-checkers.
They were like, 
"This pattern repeats, it matches, it fits, I will present it as fact".

It didn't matter if the content was factual--that wasn't the determining factor, it was more, 
Does this fit? 

And with all humans, the "fit" that matters is (often) emotional---the feeling of the matter. 
Confirmation bias: we believe what slots into what we already believe, which is first formed by our earliest experiences, not logical reasoning...

A coworker told me, for instance, that Valentine's Day was named after the Valentine's Day Massacre. 

This fit into his view that everything in the public realm is a government cover-up--
everything is suspect.

Experientially, that made perfect sense for him, coming from generational lack of access to self-determination, power, money, education, etc.

You know? If I pointed out that VD pre-dates the massacre by centuries, it wouldn't touch the mechanism of his belief. (So I didn't even.)

[––––Fact checking...

Saint Valentine was a Christian (or more than one) martyred in Roman times, but his feast day wasn't romantic, originally.
First written note of that is in Chaucer's poem “Parliament of Fowls,” (1382):
In modern English: 
“For this was on Saint Valentine’s Day,

When every bird comes there to choose his mate.” 

...end Fact Checking––––]

In my coworker's life, 
The Powers That Be operate in a Black Box--
he cannot see how they work nor feel he has any control over it.

And it's wild that AI operates in a Black Box:
humans cannot track its "reasoning"--its pattern-making is beyond us---and there's this huge danger, of course.
When recent AI agents get out of their sandbox, its minders can't even know what to patch up because it's not that simple.
It doesn't work that way, 
and that's hard to grasp.

Anyway, it's all so fascinating!

And now I'm off to a Saturday morning OA meeting, because the Monday night one is so small, I thought I'd better look for one with more people...

Also, today is No Kings, but I didn't even hear about it until yesterday! Did you?
I'd wondered where those protests went.
I'm not going though--to begin with, I had no time to make a sign, which is its greatest appeal to me, to tell the truth.

Yes--tell the truth.
But first you have to figure out, What is truth?

Hahah hahaaa, like Jesus asked Pilate.

These old questions. 
"What do you mean by that?"
They really are the way, 
and there's no shortcut but to take it yourself.

But you can take some friends along!
From my old workspace in Housewares.
 (I left them there... *pang* 
but I have plenty like them here at home.)

2 comments:

  1. it is worrying when people use artificial aids instead of real thinking or reading.

    I suppose reading a blog online or a book on kindle...i.e. just a screen..isn't "real"...but have their uses.
    Educational research seems to be pointing in the direction of realising that reading paper books and writing by hand lead to better learning and understanding

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well... what do we mean by "real"?
      LOL
      But I think I know what you mean--
      -people have all sorts of analogies for the role on AI in thinking.
      -recently I heard, and liked, that it's like taking a helicopter to the top of Mt Everest:

      Nice view, but you didn't get there yourself.

      Talking, listening in person is the realest kind of communication.
      (Oral Storytelling---almost a lost art...)

      Writing and reading are fairly newfangled technologies.


      Delete